Brother Starling –
The World We Broke (2026)
Album Review

The World We Broke gets 4 out 5 Scum Drops from me. Read all about it, below.

Hello reader,

Welcome back. Or welcome if this is your first time at SWT. Stick around for a while.

Today, we’re going to delve into Brother Starling. A press release about the band’s newest album articulates their bio as such: “Philadelphia-based Brother Starling has always lived somewhere between the roots of American music and the pull of rock and roll. The five-piece has built its sound around heartfelt songwriting, layered guitars and keyboards, vocal harmonies, and a rhythm section capable of moving from quiet restraint to full-band release. Brother Starling is Geremiah Giampa (vocals/guitar), Tom Mellon (drums/vocals), Brian Fin (bass), Mike Rusch (guitar), and Joe Ryan (guitar/keyboards/vocals).”

The band’s discography includes their debut full-length album, The Weight Of Change (2020), and the Between Then & Now EP (2026). And today, Friday, November 20th, the indie, roots, and rock band will release their sophomore full-length album, The World We Broke. Derek Chafin produced and engineered it at Barn Sound in Chester Springs, PA. This isn’t his first rodeo with the band; Chafin has worked on all three releases. Peter Humphreys at Masterwork Recording, Inc. mastered the album.

The band Brother Starling. Photo courtesy of the artist.

The release talks about the album further, noting that it “…features ten original songs and finds Brother Starling expanding their defining melodic rock sound while pushing into new sonic territory. Layered guitars, keyboards, harmonies and atmospheric textures sit alongside a live-band looseness and an emphasis on melody, hooks and classic songcraft. The album that looks squarely at the strange, fractured world of the past several years without surrendering to it.

The album follows Brother Starling’s 2020 release The Weight of Change and represents years of writing, recording and evolution for the band. Where that earlier record arrived just before the world abruptly shut down, The World We Broke emerges from everything that followed.

The result is a record that feels contemporary without abandoning the things Brother Starling has always valued: songs that can be played loud, melodies that stay with you, and lyrics grounded in recognizable human experience. At its heart, The World We Broke is an album about trying to remain connected in a time seemingly designed to pull people apart.

These ten songs move through grief, technology, addiction, manipulation, love, anxiety, political and cultural division, and the relentless noise of modern life. But the album isn’t interested in offering easy answers. Instead, it follows people attempting to navigate the confusion—to recognize what’s been lost, hold onto one another and find some measure of hope inside it.”

And now for a good representation of the album via a handful of the album’s songs. Some hype via the Brother Starling’s YouTube channel, and the Brother Starling – Topic:

The opening track, “Cost And Allure”:

(All credits and rights to Brother Starling)

The second track, “Give It Time”:

(All credits and rights to Brother Starling)

The gorgeous song, “Fall Or Fly”:

(All credits and rights to Brother Starling)

The penultimate, “Let Love Lead You”:

(All credits and rights to Brother Starling)

And last but not least, the closing song, “Home”:

(All credits and rights to Brother Starling)

The World We Broke is an album that some listeners will love on first listen, and one that will grow on others with a few listens. That’s not a negative about its songcraft, sound, or earworm-worthy melodies, but rather a recognition that full processing and reflection happen over time. And that’s a good thing. Reader, take the time to do so with each album you listen to.

There’s a lot to like about this album, from the opening bass groove laid down by Brian Fin in the opening track “Cost And Allure” or the groove from Fin in “Lost In Space” to the stripped-down melody of the closing song, “Home,” that fully showcases frontman Geremiah Giampa’s pleas within his vocal delivery. He retains a fantastic vocal delivery throughout this album. The harmonious and choral-sounding moments are well placed. The second song is also a standout, featuring Giampa’s vocals. I think for some listeners, the melodies and the band’s songcraft and musicianship of this melodic rock style music will stand out first and foremost. Melodies that show off their influences of the past while also creating their own path as a band in the present. The melodies will stand out to many initial listeners more than the lyrics and themes the album’s songwriters are trying to convey. On the second listen and subsequent listens, pay attention to the songwriting and lyrics, as there is more depth, reflection, and exploration that a listener may not understand or appreciate on the first listen. Frustrating relationships, absence, isolation, searching, and the desire to reconnect are a handful. Listen for yourself and see what else is present.

The album features a good variety of melodies, including the ones mentioned above, but also the gorgeous, synth-heavy “Without You” and the organ-driven “Let Love Lead You,” or the drum-led (kudos to Tom Mellon) and guitar-matched (kudos to most of the rest of the band) melody of “Yesterday’s Light.” A song that seems to combine the above sounds while also being quite reflective in thought is “Lost In Space”. Or the slowed-down waltz that is “The Tide”, which is sure to be the slow dance song during live shows for the band and its fans, both new and long-term. Then there are songs whose lyrics are so on their sleeve and raw with emotion they’ll both cut you and stick with you from the first listen. “Fall And Fly” is one of several within The World We Broke.

All that being said, The World We Broke gets 4 out of 5 Scum Drops from me. Overall, it is a very good release relative to all full-length albums this year, which places it well within the 72nd-83rd percentile. I would say the lower end of that range, based on a few listens. Which is damn good. While the band’s discography is limited, at this point I would say this release is just behind their Laurel Canyon-heavy sound debut, The Weight Of Change, to me. Long-time or casual fans may disagree, and that’s part of the beauty of music: it is subjective, and ok to do so. Listen to both and see what you think. Add this album to your collection in the format of your choice.

I’ll always advocate taking the time to listen to every album in its entirety. Listening to The World We Broke will take a mere 34 minutes from start to finish. And thus, only 68 minutes if you listen twice back-to-back. Along the way, you’ll discover your own favorite songs free from the influence or bias of others. After several listens, I found the songs emboldened below to be my favorites on this album.

The tracklist for The World We Broke (song length)

  1. Cost And Allure (3:21)
  2. Give It Time (3:00)
  3. Without You (3:30)
  4. Not Sleeping (2:45)
  5. Lost In Space (3:13)
  6. Fall Or Fly (3:46)
  7. Yesterday’s Light (3:36)
  8. The Tide (3:19)
  9. Let Love Lead You (4:02)
  10. Home (3:36)

Total runtime: 34:08

Check out Brother Starling’s site, their Linktree, Bandcamp, YouTube, Apple Music, and Spotify. And their socials: Facebook and Instagram.

Thank you for reading this and supporting good music.

Until next time,

Alex

From Philly? Check out more music from the City right here. Like reading album reviews?  Check out more of those right here. 

Co-Founder, Reviewer, Content Creator, Business side, Editor at  | USA | Web

Scummy Water Tower Productions co-founder, reviewer, business manager, and editor. Thank you for visiting this site, scummywatertower.com, and YouTube for our Water Tower Sessions and SWT Interviews series. And for checking out all of our socials.
Questions, feedback, or more? Contact me: alex@scummywatertower.com

Contribute

Stay in Touch

Latest

Singles Spotlight: Lefty Parker – “Punish Me”

Hello reader, How are you today? Welcome back, or welcome if...

Singles Spotlight: Dead II Society – “Lean On”

Hello reader, How are you today? Welcome back, or welcome if...

Singles Spotlight: Chris Acker – “Tinned Fish and Natural Wine”

Hello reader, How are you today? Welcome back, or welcome if...

Finding New Meaning in an Old Song By Erika Brett of The Empty Pockets (Artist Essay)

Editor's Note: The Empty Pockets are a blues, Americana...

Freddy Trujillo – Ave Trujillo (2026) Album Review

Hello reader, Welcome back. Today, we're going to explore an American...

View All Coverage
By Year

Related Posts

Singles Spotlight: Lefty Parker – “Punish Me”

Hello reader, How are you today? Welcome back, or welcome if this is your first visit to SWT. Please look around the site and stay awhile....

Singles Spotlight: Dead II Society – “Lean On”

Hello reader, How are you today? Welcome back, or welcome if this is your first visit to SWT. Please look around the site and stay awhile....

Singles Spotlight: Chris Acker – “Tinned Fish and Natural Wine”

Hello reader, How are you today? Welcome back, or welcome if this is your first visit to SWT. Please look around the site and stay awhile....
The World We Broke gets 4 out 5 Scum Drops from me. Read all about it, below.Brother Starling - The World We Broke (2026) Album Review